Chile’s 9/11…

September 11, 1973, a tragic day for Chile.  A CIA-engineered coup brought Augusto Pinochet to power.  Following in the steps of Nazi-lover Stroessner in Paraguay and blazing trails for Argentina’s military junta, the Generalisimo was evil incarnate.  His and his evil twins’ fascism in southern South America set a new standard for torture and killing.  If there is a Catholic hell, he is probably the Devil’s right-hand man.  As in Argentina, everyone that crossed his regime was declared a communist or Jewish terrorist, brought up before a military tribunal, if they were lucky, tortured in jail, and dumped into mass graves with other bullet-riddled corpses.

During most of the second half of the 20th century, anti-communist paranoia reigned supreme in Washington D.C.  Starting with McCarthy, many politicians made their names by jumping on the anti-communist bandwagon.  Nixon made his name in trumped-up proceedings in Congress, playing his anti-pinko cards just right to eventually become president.  The Dulles brothers ruined the Middle East for years to come.  Reagan became famous by running actors out of the country and nearly destroying the University of California.  If you questioned American foreign policy, you were declared a puppet of Moscow or Peking.  Many progressives, myself included, learned to keep mouths shut and eyes watchful.  Anyone to the left of the Rotary Club was a bleeding-heart pinko communist.

As a country, we’ve come to our senses—a little bit, at least.  While socialism is still a cuss word tripping off many a right-winger’s fascist and forked tongue, the fall of the Soviet Union and the morphing of China into the kind of fascist-capitalistic system most American industrial leaders would love to have (poverty wages, few benefits, and no unions), we have few people ranting in Congress about communists.  Of course, there was Allen West, Florida’s McCarthy reincarnation, but he was tossed out on his butt after just one term.  Other Tea Party canards have focused more on defining rape for women, promoting campaigns against same-sex marriages, and being obstructionist in just about everything to get even with Obama.

I’m not sure we’ve learned from history, though.  Go to my webpage “Steve’s Bookshelf” {/?page_id=23}.  Under non-fiction, you will see Stephen’s Kinzer’s book Overthrow.  In it, you will find thirteen case studies of how the U.S. government has overthrown completely legitimate governments in its rush to manifest destiny and later to keep the world safe from communism.  Chile is but one example.  The list is already out-of-date too.  It starts with Hawaii (ask a native Hawaiian what he or she thinks of the overthrow of their queen—I have).  I’m not certain whether Reagan’s folly, Grenada, was included, but I’m certain Bush’s folly, Iraq, was not.

Now we are really worried that Iran will develop nuclear weapons.  They don’t need super-accurate missiles to launch them against Israel, you know.  Just a few scattered around will start an arms race in the Middle East.  (Never mind the fact that Israel has atomic weapons—I’ll bet their missiles are a lot more accurate, too.)  But we caused the whole botched-up foreign policy mess we call Iran.  The British oil company that became BP wasn’t happy with the royalties they were getting from the Iranian prime minister.  They asked the Dulles brothers to help.  The latter were only too glad to declare the prime minister a communist and have the CIA engineer another coup.  The Shah came into power.  Overturning his brutal regime led to the Islamic Revolution in Iran.  The story’s all there in Kinzer’s book.

Back to Chile.  What makes these stories so sad are the personal tragedies.  I recently reviewed Edgardo David Holzman’s Malena, historical fiction about the dark days of the junta in Argentina.  I don’t know about Chile, but the anti-Semitic pogroms in Aregentina are only second to the “final solution” that took place in Nazi Germany.  In both countries, university professors and students, LGBTs, dissidents—just about anybody daring to disagree with the regimes—were rounded up, tortured, and killed.  The U.S. caused both of these national tragedies.  The Chilean tragedy was instigated by American business interests that didn’t want the newly elected government to nationalize the copper mines.  Argentina was more hidden and insidious (read my review of Holzman’s book—better still, read the book!).

Every American should know about the horror we caused in these regime changes.  More specifically, every American should have to relive in words some of the personal tragedies.  A case in point: just recently eight people were charged with Victor Jara’s murder.  Who is Victor Jara, you ask?  I suppose the CIA and the Pinochet government would call him a Marxist-Leninist dissident.  Our foreign policy leaders and media wonks are good at smear tactics—always have been; always will be.  Our far-right nutcakes are good at it too—how else was Allen West elected?  Point a finger, call a person a name, whether true or not—it’s the modern version of the Salem witch trials.

Victor Jara was a university professor and a folksinger.  If memory serves me, he played the guitar left-handed.  I learned some of his story while living in Bogotá, Colombia.  Some months before the CIA-engineered coup, we took a trip around South America.  We were enamored with the Chileans and their beautiful country.  Chile seemed to be the place California ought to be.  They were hard-working, fun-loving, and very hopeful for a new future with the elections that brought Allende to power.

Time marches on.  Later, in our Bogotá apartment building, we enjoyed a small but progressive UN-like environment.  Our nextdoor neighbors were Italian (the husband was in fact Libyan, born there during the time of Mussolini—how he hated the man).  A Chilean and Colombian couple shared the apartment above us.  The Colombian man became my doctor (his son disappeared in Guatemala at the hands of another dictatorship).  The Chilean man had been the transportation secretary in Allende’s cabinet and had barely escaped Pinochet’s brutal regime.

We received a first-hand account of what happened to Victor Jara and many other Chileans.  The folksinger was arrested along with many university students.  He was tortured.  Some of his torturers thought it would be amusing to cut off his hands so he couldn’t play the guitar anymore (I assume this story is true—I’m repeating details heard from the ex-transportation secretary, but they haven’t appeared anywhere in our lackluster media releases).  I guess those torturers didn’t have much chance to enjoy their blood games.  On September 14, 1973, Victor Jara was found dead.  He had been shot 44 times.

Incredibly, the story is not over.  One of Jara’s murders living in Florida is fighting extradition.  A firing squad would be too lenient for him and his cohorts—nevertheless, it’s doubtful that any of them will be tried.  The U.S. government certainly won’t be cooperative.  (FYI, the CIA taught torture techniques to both the Argentine and Chilean juntas as “consultants.”)  Unfortunately, Chileans don’t have such a dedicated group like the one that went after Eichmann and other Nazi murderers.  Fascists in Latin America tend to get away with their crimes because current regimes were often peripherally involved at least.

Justice moves slowly there, if there is any justice at all.  Mothers in Chile and Argentina still pace in the city plazuelas and protest, wondering what happened to their children.  Refugees still wonder whether it’s really safe to return to their home countries.  And human beings’ capacity to maim and murder never seems to diminish.  Mercedes Sosa escaped Argentina to sing her songs of protest and win the hearts of people everywhere.  Victor Jara never had the chance.

And so it goes….

[If you enjoyed this post, support this blog: buy, read, and review my books.]

4 Responses to “Chile’s 9/11…”

  1. Dawn Olenski Says:

    Steve,

    I wish I had known you were interested in Chilean history. I took an international ethics class last year and went to Chile. One of the most fascinating and beautiful places I have been. The fact that the Chilean people have been working for years to heal the wounds of September 11th 1973 is an amazing feat. I can share some amazing pictures with you if you want of one of the places that the “missing” went. They have removed the stone gate/fence and replaced it with plexiglass, so nothing can be hidden from site anymore. I can send you a lot of great information about this and Chile’s current economics.

  2. steve Says:

    Hi Dawn,
    Thank you for your comments. Every time a reader or writer makes a comment like this, I think, “Well, that justifies this blog.” Such comments mean that I have touched someone with a common theme.
    I grew up in California. Latin America contributed to my culture, along with Asian, Armenian, and many other areas of the world. I went to UC Santa Barbara where Embarcadero del Norte was the main thoroughfare through its little college town, Isla Vista. Instead of U.S. history, I took Latin American history, taught by a Jesuit who didn’t gloss over the trials and tribulations, from O’Higgins and his many children to land grabbing and Native American massacres.
    I read extensively in the literature coming from Spanish-speaking Latin America and Spain. I even review some of what I read–in Spanish, at times, although I speak and read the language better than I write it.
    When we were in Santiago and Valapariso, we met Chileans with many hopes for the future and a wariness about what their fascist military might do about Allende. All hell broke loose during the next few years, turning most of the South American continent into a totalitarian disaster. Both Chile and Argentina participated in the CIA’s Operation Condor, along with other countries. The agents were willing collaborators in killings, tortures, and making people disappear. Our children won’t read about this in our U.S. history books. Only in tales of victims like Jara and books like Malena will people begin to see the duplicity of our government.
    Sorry to rant like this, but ethics is what it’s all about. Our foreign policies are not moral in too many instances. The Ugly American is very real. He’s not your average American strolling down Main Street U.S.A. He’s a bureaucrat in Washington who unilaterally determines that his fascist ideas are right for the country and the world.
    Many of my books have a government conspiracy tone to them. My new novel, The Golden Years of Virginia Morgan, to be released this year, is probably one of the most chilling. As usual, I hope the fiction that I write doesn’t become reality.
    All the best,
    Steve
    P.S. I’d be interested in seeing pictures of the places where the “missing” went in Chile. Chile’s current economic status seems healthy, especially considering what went on under Pinochet. I’d be interested in that too. I try to keep up with many situations around the world, but one can never have too much information. 🙂

  3. Scott Says:

    Hello, Steve,
    This entry brought to mind a story which probably doesn’t add much to the discussion but…

    When I was in college, a group of us decided to go see the movie MISSING starring Jack Lemmon. I’m sure you remember it. We had to walk a few blocks west of campus to get to the theater, and arrived about 5 minutes after the movie started. I really hadn’t heard anything much about the movie; one of my friends had suggested it.

    I watched, horrified by the events it depicted, and at the end (because I wasn’t real strong on South American geography and didn’t get the ‘place’ references in the movie) I asked my friend where that had happened.

    A hippie-ish guy behind us heard me and started giving it to me. “What do you mean where was it? It’s because of people like you who don’t know where that happened that it keeps happening!” (He didn’t answer my question anyway.) I turned to him, taken aback, and said, “Sorry man, I missed the beginning,” to which he replied, “You missed the beginning? Where the hell were you in 1973?”

    My buddy turned to him and said, “We were 13 years old, buddy! Where the hell were you?”

    That said, there was some truth to what he said. It wasn’t part of our consciousness in 1973, when I was probably in 7th grade, and no one in our part of the country even knew it was happening! (sorry for the long-ish comment…)

  4. steve Says:

    Hi Scott,
    Thank you, thank you, for this input. I never saw the movie Missing. Let me explain why.
    The movie was based on the book The Execution of Charles Horman by Thomas Hauser. As far as I know, it was never shown in Colombia, where I was living at the time (Colombia was having its own problems with the usual guerrilla bands and another group called M-19–it doesn’t surprise me that there was a strong censorship). However, I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt–I was travelling a lot internationally at the time. I wouldn’t have seen the movie in the U.S. as I was passing through either. The film and the book were removed from the U.S. market after a lawsuit was filed against the director Costa-Gavras and Universal’s parent company MCA by former Ambassador Nathaniel Davis. Reagan was President and my impression is that many U.S. ambassadors to Latin America were willing participants in Operation Condor–I met the one in Colombia and the only thing we had in common was that we both had ties to UC Santa Barbara. The book now appears on Amazon as a “collectible.” I guess no one wants to re-issue it. I don’t know about the movie.
    I would love to see the movie. Apparently the score was written by Vangelis and has never been released. Ironically, exerts from the score have been used in commercials. Hypocrisy at the corporate level?
    BTW, this is yet another example of why the Academy Awards have become irrelevant for me. Both Cannes and the Golden Globes are more telling about quality film making. Lemmon was nominated for his role in missing but only won in Cannes, I believe.
    All the best,
    Steve