News and Notices from the Writing Trenches #96…
Friday, July 17th, 2015Item. Mockingbird follow-up. Well, well, yet another case of the media looking for scandal! It turns out that the sequel to Harper Lee’s classic is creating a scandal because the grown-up Scout, after living in NYC for some time, returns to Alabama to find old Atticus has become a racist bigot. I found To Kill a Mockingbird a rough ride—disorganized ups and downs as the two different stories unfolded (only the trial appeared in the movie)—so maybe I’ll like this one better. I don’t have any emotional stake in Atticus the good guy v. Atticus the bad guy. The author wouldn’t get away with that today. Critics are saying that Lee’s old editor knew what he (she?) was doing by rejecting the original and encouraging a rewrite. Maybe not. This sequel, written before the famous novel, might have been the better book. Of course, coming out now, it’s a poignant reminder that racism and bigotry is still a national problem.
Item. A thank you. Authors don’t do it enough, but I want to express my thanks to all readers who take the time to review the books they’ve read. I don’t have many reviews, but I value every one of them, even the negative ones, because the person took the time to review. Through reviews an author can learn the likes and dislikes of his readers (but email correspondence works too). While readers often use more than reviews, and should (see below), when selecting their reading material, it’s clear that reviews can provide useful information for doing just that. So, thanks to all the reviewers out there.
Item. Star reviewers. Don’t worry, writers: I’m not creating a list to compete with Amazon’s star reviewer list. One not containing 90% product reviewers is sorely needed, but I don’t have the time or the data. No, here I’m talking about the wide range of reviewers’ interpretations of the Amazon star ranking system. Many book bloggers use it, and there’s a wide range there too. Let’s face it: the star-system isn’t uniformly applied, it’s primarily a convenience for Amazon (they can computerize all their book reviews), and readers often take the shortcut of counting stars instead of reading the review. I’d do away with it, period, because achieving consensus about its application is impossible. (I won’t use it in book reviews here and, in my official book reviewing capacity at Bookpleasures, it’s not used. Of course, Goodreads uses it—their nexus is far too tight with Amazon.)
