Review of Beverly Garside’s I and You…
Wednesday, July 2nd, 2014(Beverly Garside, I and You, 2013, CreateSpace, 978-1492187424)
How delicious satire is when it’s well done! Irish have it in their DNA—just look at Shaw, Wilde, Swift, and others who have skewered the British elites—so I love satire even though I can’t write it well. Political satire, of course, is generally hated by the satirized and loved by those who agree with it. In this book, you’ll find political satire that is hilarious in its best moments and at least enjoyable in its worst, unless you’re a Libertarian. If you fall into that cult that worships in Ayn Rand’s church, this book is probably not for you.
I’ve never reviewed a graphic novel before, but this one was so intriguing I couldn’t resist. I came to the conclusion I might be doing something like this now if I’d had any success making my own comic books as I learned to read and not to draw between ages three and four. My art was bad and what I put in those balloons was probably only slightly better. Fine satire is always embedded in an interesting story, and Ms. Garside puts many entertaining things in those balloons and figure captions to make one. Duimstra, the artist, has drawn well too, although I can only judge it with an amateur’s eyes. I like what I read and see.
